نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسنده
گروه پژوهشی ارزیابی و توسعه منابع علمی.مؤسسه استنادی و پایش علم و فناوری جهان اسلام. شیراز. ایران
چکیده
کلیدواژهها
عنوان مقاله [English]
نویسنده [English]
Purpose: Religious studies has gained a significant position within the production and dissemination of scholarly knowledge in the humanities in Iran. Despite the growing number of scholarly journals in this field, a systematic assessment of their structural characteristics, citation status, and patterns of scientific impact based on scientometric indicators remains necessary. This study aimed to examine the structural characteristics of religion-related journals indexed in the Islamic World Science Citation Center (ISC) and to analyze their relative citation status and inter-journal citation network.
Methodology: This descriptive-analytical study was conducted using a scientometric approach. The study population consisted of 18 religion-related journals indexed in ISC. Descriptive statistics, Kendall’s coefficient of concordance, and the Wilcoxon signed-rank test were used for data analysis. Gephi software was also employed to analyze the inter-journal citation network.
Findings: The results showed that universities and religious institutions accounted for 77.8% of the journals under study, representing the largest share of publishers. Geographically, 72.2% of the journals were concentrated in the provinces of Qom and Tehran. In terms of subject orientation, 77.8% of the journals were classified within the religion–humanities category, while 22.2% had interdisciplinary orientations. The analysis of citation status within subject categories showed that 83.3% of the journals were ranked in the third and fourth quartiles, and none were placed in the first quartile. Based on three citation indicators—impact, cumulative citations, and h-index—Psychology and Religion demonstrated the highest overall performance among the journals. Kendall’s coefficient of concordance indicated a significant agreement among the rankings derived from the citation indicators, suggesting that journals performing better on one indicator generally tended to achieve higher rankings on the others. Regarding the contribution of journal self-citation to citation impact, removing self-citations did not substantially alter the impact indicator for most journals, and the Wilcoxon signed-rank test revealed no statistically significant difference. However, self-citation played a considerable role in some journals; for example, approximately 40% of the impact indicator of Religion, Spirituality & Management Studies was attributable to self-citations. This finding highlights the importance of considering the citation structure of individual journals when interpreting impact indicators, as dependence on self-citation varies across journals. After excluding self-citations, the citation network among the 18 journals consisted of 29 links with a total weight of 51 and a density of 0.19. The network structure revealed a relative concentration of citation flows around a small number of journals, particularly Philosophy of Religion, New Religious Thought, and Religions and Mysticism.
Conclusion: Overall, the findings indicate that religion-related journals indexed in ISC have considerable potential to enhance their scientific impact despite several challenges. Their major strengths include the active role of universities and religious institutions in scholarly publishing, the favorable citation performance of some journals—particularly those with interdisciplinary orientations—and the limited dependence of the impact indicators of most journals on self-citation. The latter may reflect a greater contribution of citations received from the wider scholarly community to their citation impact. In contrast, the concentration of most journals in the third and fourth citation quartiles and their geographical concentration represent notable challenges. Accordingly, strengthening interdisciplinary approaches, expanding scholarly interactions, and improving article visibility may contribute to enhancing the citation status of religion-related journals within Iran’s scientific system.
کلیدواژهها [English]